Material comparison
All seven countertop materials, side by side.
Every material we fabricate has real strengths and real limits. This guide puts the specs in one place so you can see exactly where they differ and what those differences mean for a working kitchen in the Midlands.
The full comparison
| Spec | Granite | Engineered Quartz | Quartzite | Marble | Soapstone | Dolomite | Travertine |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Origin | Natural | Engineered | Natural | Natural | Natural | Natural | Natural |
| Hardness (Mohs) | 6–7 | 7 | 7–8 | 3–5 | 2–3.5 | 3.5–4 | 3–4 |
| Heat resistance | Excellent | Low | High | Moderate | Excellent | Moderate | Moderate |
| Stain resistance | High | Excellent | Low | Low | High | Moderate | Low |
| Scratch resistance | High | High | Very high | Low | Low | Moderate | Low |
| Etch resistance | Excellent | Excellent | High | Low | Excellent | Low | Low |
| Needs sealing | Yes | No | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Relative cost | $$ $$$ | $$ $$$ | $$$ $$$$ | $$$ $$$$ | $$$ | $$$ | $$ $$$ |
Head-to-head comparisons
Each pair has its own page with a direct-answer summary, a detailed spec breakdown, and the honest "which one" guidance we give customers in the shop.
Compare
Granite vs. Marble
Granite handles the kitchen better than marble does, full stop.
See full comparisonCompare
Granite vs. Quartz
This is the most common decision we see in the shop, and it usually comes down to one question: how do you cook? Granite handles heat better.
See full comparisonCompare
Granite vs. Quartzite
Both granite and quartzite are natural stone, and both need sealing, but that's roughly where the similarity ends.
See full comparisonCompare
Marble vs. Quartz
This comparison often comes up when someone loves the marble look but has heard the horror stories about etching and staining.
See full comparisonCompare
Marble vs. Quartzite
Marble and quartzite can look strikingly similar in a showroom, both offering white-and-grey veining with natural movement, but they're entirely different minerals with different performance profiles.
See full comparisonCompare
Quartz vs. Quartzite
These two get confused constantly.
See full comparisonCompare
Dolomite vs. Marble
Dolomite is a step up from marble in hardness (Mohs 3.
See full comparisonCompare
Dolomite vs. Quartzite
These two materials get confused in showrooms constantly, and the confusion is sometimes deliberate: softer stones get labeled "quartzite" because it's a premium-sounding name.
See full comparisonCompare
Granite vs. Soapstone
Granite and soapstone both handle heat well, but that's roughly where the similarity ends.
See full comparisonCompare
Granite vs. Travertine
For a kitchen countertop, granite wins this comparison easily.
See full comparisonCompare
Marble vs. Soapstone
Marble and soapstone are both soft natural stones that develop character over time, but they have opposite weakness profiles.
See full comparisonCompare
Marble vs. Travertine
Marble and travertine are both calcite-based natural stones, both etch from acids, and both are softer than granite or quartzite.
See full comparisonCompare
Quartz vs. Soapstone
Quartz and soapstone share an uncommon trait: neither needs sealing.
See full comparisonCompare
Dolomite vs. Granite
Granite is the clear choice for a kitchen countertop in this matchup.
See full comparisonCompare
Dolomite vs. Quartz
For a kitchen that sees real cooking, quartz wins this comparison and it's not especially close.
See full comparisonCompare
Dolomite vs. Soapstone
These two materials look nothing alike and behave very differently.
See full comparisonCompare
Dolomite vs. Travertine
Neither material is well-suited to a primary kitchen prep surface, but if you're choosing between the two, dolomite is the more appropriate countertop stone.
See full comparisonCompare
Quartz vs. Travertine
Quartz wins this comparison for kitchen use, and it's not close.
See full comparisonCompare
Quartzite vs. Soapstone
Quartzite and soapstone are both natural stones that don't etch from kitchen acids, which puts them in better company than marble, dolomite, or travertine for a working kitchen.
See full comparisonCompare
Quartzite vs. Travertine
Quartzite is one of the best natural stone choices for a kitchen countertop.
See full comparisonCompare
Soapstone vs. Travertine
Both soapstone and travertine are soft natural stones, and that's roughly where the similarity ends.
See full comparisonStill not sure which material is right for you?
Come see real slabs at the showroom in Cayce. We can pull samples of any material side by side, talk through your kitchen and how you cook, and give you a straight answer. No upsell.